23 competitor data points contractors can track

Key takeaways
  • Use 23 fields across reviews, permits, web presence, hiring and advertised pricing as a worksheet, not a scorecard.
  • Date each observation and leave unavailable fields blank. A review or permit count does not measure completed jobs.
  • Compare businesses that compete for the same customers and use the findings to choose what to check in your own operation.

A competitor worksheet can keep scattered observations in one place. The 23 fields below are options for three businesses serving the same customers as yours. You do not need to fill every field before the comparison is useful.

Set up the worksheet

Use one row per business, with its name, website and the date of each observation. Keep the raw number or exact wording beside a link to the public record. Add a notes column for a decision you can actually make. Three comparable businesses are a practical starting point, not a rule.

Set a review schedule based on the question at hand. A fast-changing review total may be checked more often than a service-page list or permit archive. Record the source and date every time so an old entry does not look current.

Review intelligence (6 data points)

1. Total Google review count

Record the displayed count and the date observed. Search for the correct business location before comparing totals.

2. Net review-count change

Subtract the earlier displayed total from the later one. This is net change, not a count of new jobs or even all reviews posted; Google may delay or remove reviews. Google explains missing and delayed reviews.

3. Average star rating

Record the displayed rating beside the review count. A small rating change may be rounding rather than a clear change in customer experience.

4. Recent review ratings

Read a defined sample of recent public reviews and record its size and dates. Do not treat that sample as the rating of every customer.

5. Owner response in the sample

Count visible owner replies in the same review sample. State the sample size; a response is evidence of a public reply, not proof a complaint was resolved.

6. Recurring complaint topics

Note specific topics in the reviews you read. Verify the pattern across more than one account before changing your own message. Google recommends genuine review requests and prohibits incentives for reviews. See its review guidance.

Permit intelligence (4 data points)

Permit records vary by authority, trade, date field and search coverage. Check the portal’s definitions before comparing businesses. Do not treat a filing as a completed job.

7. Permits in a recent window

Search the local authority’s public records by business name and document the exact filing or issuance date field. Permit coverage differs by trade and jurisdiction.

8. Permits in a longer window

Use the same portal, identity rule and date field for a broader comparison window. Do not add permits from a different jurisdiction without labeling the change.

9. Recorded permit values

Sum values only where the portal provides comparable amounts. A stated value can be an estimate or a declared project cost, not money the contractor collected.

10. Permit locations

Map the work locations or postal codes shown on matching records, respecting address privacy. Work location can help identify overlap, but one record cannot prove a territory strategy.

Web intelligence (5 data points)

11. Visible website changes

Save the page and observation date before calling a later version a change. A footer copyright year is not a reliable last-update timestamp.

12. Service-specific pages

Count distinct pages that explain a service, rather than counting every menu item or location variant as a separate service.

13. Business Profile post activity

Record the date of a visible post if the profile shows one.

14. Visible profile photos

Record what you can see and when you checked. A photo date or displayed order may not reveal a regular upload schedule.

15. Search result positions

Search the same terms, area and device context and date each observation. Positions change and local results depend on relevance, distance and prominence. Google explains local ranking. For your own site, Search Console shows query and page trends in clicks and impressions.

Hiring intelligence (4 data points)

16. Open job listings

Record the role, location, employer and date for each public listing. Duplicates and staffing-agency posts can distort a simple count.

17. Listing history

Note when a posting was observed and whether it reappears.

18. Advertised pay

Copy the disclosed range and pay period, with the role and location. A job ad is an offered range, not a verified wage paid to every worker.

19. Advertised benefits

Record the stated benefits and eligibility terms. Compare the advertised package to your own documented offer without assuming every applicant receives it.

Public prices and permit values (4 data points)

Public offers and quotes obtained for real work describe customer-facing prices or terms. Permit values are recorded project amounts, not public offers or invoices. Keep those columns separate, and compare prices only with their scope and terms.

20. Comparable customer quotes

Use quotes from legitimate customer requests that the customer permits you to compare. Match scope, materials, location, exclusions and date before comparing prices.

21. Advertised promotions

Record the offer text, date and conditions.

22. Advertised financing

Record the provider, term and qualifications the competitor actually displays. Confirm current terms before using them in your own sales discussion.

23. Permit-value average

If comparable permit records carry values, divide their sum by the count of valued records. Label the result a permit-value average, not average ticket size, revenue or profit.

Turn a change into a decision

Choose one field linked to your next decision. If you notice public complaints about missed calls, check how your own shop answers and follows up before changing your advertising. If a competitor has more service pages, inspect whether your customers can find and understand the work you actually perform.

For your own website, compare Search Console clicks and impressions by query and page when investigating a change in visibility or inquiries.

Start with one comparison

Name businesses that sell the same work in your area. Record their review totals, visible services and one dated source for each. Add permit or hiring records only where you can identify the business and the source defines the field. Write down the question you want the next observation to answer.

The Laws of the Contractor’s Campaign index collects the related guides.

Frequently asked questions

What competitor data should a contractor track?

Start with review counts and ratings, permitted work where records are available, service pages and search visibility, public hiring posts, and advertised prices or financing. The 23 fields above provide a fuller worksheet, but a blank field is better than a guess.

How often should the worksheet be updated?

Check review totals at a pace you can maintain. Recheck permits, service pages and hiring posts when you have a decision to make. Date each observation so you know which entries need another look.

How many competitors should I compare?

Start with a few businesses that serve the same customers and area. Three can make the first worksheet manageable. Add or remove businesses when the comparison no longer answers your question.

Can a change in review count show how many jobs a competitor completed?

No. Subtracting two displayed totals gives net review-count change, which can also reflect removed or delayed reviews. Reviews are not a job count.

Can permit values be used as average ticket size?

A permit-value average is the sum of recorded permit values divided by the number of comparable permits with values. It is not a contractor’s actual average invoice or revenue. Check the portal’s definitions and missing records before comparing.

Should I request a quote from a competitor just for research?

Use publicly advertised offers and real customer quotes you are authorized to compare. Do not impersonate a customer or request a quote for work you do not intend to buy.

Sources and method

Google Business Profile Help: Tips to get more reviews; About missing or delayed reviews; Tips to improve your local ranking. Google Search Central: How to use Search Console. Google guidance reviewed October 15, 2026. Permit and hiring entries are worksheet suggestions, not measured results for named competitors; verify local record definitions before use.

See what your contractor website makes clear to customers

KKS offers a free contractor audit for qualifying businesses: a website and competitor review with a 15-factor, 150-point scorecard, comparison with three local competitors, and a 90-day action plan. If we cannot find three defensible matches, we resolve the scope with you before accepting the audit. Qualified reports are delivered within two business days after KKS confirms the business, market and evidence scope. A large site or unclear identity can require a narrower scope or more time.

Request a free contractor audit

Get website and marketing help for your contracting business

KKS builds and manages contractor websites, handles local SEO, and researches your competitors to guide the work. Explore our managed website plans or start with a free audit comparing your business with three competitors.

View website and marketing plans Request my free competitor audit