TACTICAL 9 | Competitor Analysis for Contractors: Building the Intelligence File

Build a competitor analysis file from public pages and records, then update it on a schedule that fits your market. Start with a small set of comparable shops, record dated signals and check your own calls and jobs before changing your offer.

A spreadsheet and a monthly calendar appointment are enough to start.

From the Watch to the File

A dated file lets you compare what changed since the last check.

Keep the same competitors, signals and sources for monthly comparisons. Date any new source or signal before adding it.

Back to Navigation

Element One: Build the Watch List

Start with three to five shops whose services and territory overlap yours.

Open Google Maps and search your main service plus your city, the way a customer would. Plumber near me. HVAC repair plus your town. Note the shops that keep showing up in the top of the map pack, because those are possible competitors for those searches. Then add the names you already know from the field, the outfit whose trucks you see on the same streets, the one your techs leave to go work for, the cheap operator your price shoppers keep mentioning. Add those names to the same watch list.

Write each competitor at the top of its own column in your sheet, along with the basics that do not change much. Business name, website, primary service area, how long they have been around if you know it. Keep those details at the top of the monthly file.

Back to Navigation

Element Two: Build the Signal Sheet

Choose the signals that fit your trade and use the same rows for each monthly check. Date any new row without filling in earlier months from memory.

Pricing and promotions

Their published prices where you can find them, their dispatch or trip fee, and any promotion running this month. An eighty nine dollar tune up, a free estimate offer, a senior discount. Date the offer and record its terms; a published price is not the rival’s cost.

Review count and velocity

Record the displayed Google review count at each dated check. The difference is the net change in the displayed total, not a count of all reviews newly posted. Use the count as a review signal, not a job or market-share measure.

Permit activity

Where it applies to your trade, the permits pulled in your county under each competitor’s name. A permit record can identify a listed contractor, job type, and location when the local portal includes those fields. It is not a full job log: some work needs no permit, names can differ, and an issued permit does not establish completed work or revenue.

Hiring and advertising

Whether they have job postings up, and whether they are running paid ads. Record the posting or ad and its date. Neither shows actual hiring or ad spend.

Footprint changes

Record a new listed location or service area, or a documented acquisition or closure, with its source and date.

Back to Navigation

Element Three: Run the Pull

Use the public sources available in your market. Permit access and platform search options vary.

County permit portal. Look for a public permit portal on your county or city building department website, often through a search portal. Search by contractor name or by address in your service area. Check the portal’s contractor and address fields, dates, and permit status. If records are not online, ask the department what public search or records-request options it offers.

Google Business Profile. Pull up each competitor’s Google listing for review count, review dates, recent photos, and any posts or offers they have published. Save the count on each monthly check. Google says more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking.[1] A single newest-review date is not a monthly change.

Their own website. Pricing pages, service area pages, financing offers, and any promotion banner. Record the advertised service area as a company claim.

Job boards. Search the competitor’s name on the big hiring sites. Record the advertised role and pay range, if stated, with the posting date.

Ad libraries. The Meta Ad Library and Google Ads Transparency Center let you search visible ads by advertiser or other available filters.[2][3] Record the search date; library coverage and timing vary. Visible ads do not show spend.

Back to Navigation

Element Four: Set the Cadence

Set a recurring monthly appointment and name an owner and backup. Keep the appointment on the calendar; if both miss it, mark the month as a gap rather than filling in observations later as if they were checked on time.

The first check includes setup. Later checks may take less time, depending on your sources and the number of shops tracked. Keep the observation date for each source so you can tell a genuine change from a gap in the record.

Back to Navigation

Element Five: Run the Read

At each monthly review, note what changed and choose a next check or a decision grounded in your own results.

First, compare dated signals with the previous check. Note changes in published promotions, net displayed review counts, permits tied to a named contractor, and service-area claims. Record the source, date and search scope. Label any missed source or monthly check as a gap.

Second, check the leading explanation against your own calls, estimates and completed jobs. For a published tune-up price, compare your own estimates and completed jobs before changing your offer. For permits under a franchise name, check the contractor identity, permit status and location, then compare your own service capacity and completed work in that area before adding a city page. Write one next check or bounded decision, its owner and the date to revisit it.

Back to Navigation

Five Moves You Run This Week

Move one. Build the sheet. Search Maps for your service in your city and choose three to five shops whose work and territory overlap yours. Record each business name, website and claimed service area.

Move two. Set comparable rows for published pricing and promotions, displayed review totals and net changes, applicable permits, hiring and ads, and footprint claims. Add a new row with its first observation date; do not backfill earlier months.

Move three. Record the first observations from available permit portals, business profiles, company sites, job boards and ad libraries. Note each source, date and search scope. Leave unavailable fields blank and label them.

Move four. Put a recurring monthly review on the calendar with an owner and backup. If it is missed, mark a gap and resume with the next dated check.

Move five. Review what the sources actually show, look for a plausible other explanation and compare the signal with your own calls and jobs. Record the next check or bounded decision, its owner and review date. Base an offer change on your own calls, estimates and completed jobs.

Back to Navigation

Key Takeaways

  • A file with fixed parts makes dated monthly comparisons easier to repeat.
  • Start with three to five comparable competitors. Compare search results with the shops you encounter in the field.
  • Track the same signals every month: pricing and promotions, review count and velocity, permits, hiring and ads, and footprint changes.
  • Many signals have public starting points: county permit portals, Google profiles, competitor websites, job boards, and the Meta and Google ad libraries.
  • Monthly review-count differences show net displayed change; they are not a count of newly posted reviews.
  • Each month, record the source and date, check another explanation and your own results, then assign a next check or bounded decision.

Next in the Series

Use the dated file to compare offers and plan your next website improvement.

For positioning guidance, see Contractor Value Proposition.

Put the competitor file to work

Qualified free audit using available public evidence: 15 factors, three relevant local competitors and a 90-day plan. Delivery within two business days after business, market and evidence scope are confirmed; large inventories or unclear business identity may change scope or timing.

KKS can use the competitor file to plan your website work around your services and market.

KKS managed websites use that plan: compare current plans and pricing

Request a Free Contractor Audit →

Use the monthly file to choose the next check for your business.

Commercial disclosure: KKS sells website services for contractors. KKS previously used affiliate links in its articles. This page has no affiliate purchase links.

Sources

  1. [1] Google Business Profile Help: local ranking and reviews
  2. [2] Meta Ad Library: search and coverage
  3. [3] Google Ads Transparency Center: active ads

Frequently Asked Questions

What is competitor analysis for contractors, in plain terms?

It is a dated file of public competitor signals you check on a schedule. Track a short list of comparable shops, record each source and note what changed. Compare the signals with your calls and completed jobs before choosing the next check.

How many competitors should I track?

Three to five is a practical starting set for a small monthly file. Choose shops with overlapping work and territory. Use Maps as one starting point, then check the names you know from the field. Add more when you can date each check and record its source.

Where do I get the data, and is any of it private?

Start with publicly available listings, websites, permit portals where offered, job boards, and ad libraries. Check access rules and record the date and scope of each search.

What is review velocity and why does it matter so much?

Review velocity here means the net change in displayed review count between dated checks, not the number of all reviews posted during that interval. Reviews can be removed or delayed, so the net displayed change may differ from the number posted.

How long does this take each month?

Allow time to set up the first sheet. Later monthly checks depend on the number of competitors, available records and the depth of your review. Keep a monthly appointment, but mark any missed check as a gap.

What do I do with the file once it is built?

Compare dated signals with the prior review and check their source and scope. Compare the signals with your calls and completed jobs. Assign a next check or decision to an owner, with a review date. Before changing prices or adding a city page, check your own capacity and customer demand.

Get website and marketing help for your contracting business

KKS builds and manages contractor websites, handles local SEO, and researches your competitors to guide the work. Explore our managed website plans or start with a free audit comparing your business with three competitors.

View website and marketing plans Request my free competitor audit